OK, I’m going to weigh in on a topic I read about on TastingTable.com
They rated Costco alcohols and put the Kirkland Signature Spiced Rum at the bottom of their list.
In some ways they can be justified for their choice BUT, allow me to weigh in.
Spiced rum is produced by macerating natural herbs and spices into white rum. The macerated rum is then aged in oak barrels. Simple and straightforward. I’ve flavored alcohol in this same manner.
Now, as TastingTable correctly points out, “Anything less than this process is a ‘rum with natural flavors,’ a label that retailers are legally required to note on the bottle”
I’ve had the Costco spiced rum in the past from their St. Croix distillery and, frankly, I enjoyed it. The newer rum does have a different flavor profile but contrary to the reviewers at TastingTable.com, I don’t rank it as suitable only for making rum cake.
I always advocate for enjoyment of flavors rather than elitism of only calling things made a certain way as being of value. This was what turned me off from wine tasting (that and I personally find most wine to be sour grape juice – but that’s just MY palate). Many tasters (of spirits or wine) become biased by what they perceive as ‘proper’ and therefore of value.
Now, bear with me – I’m saying NOTHING bad about TastingTable.com, I’m just offering an opposing viewpoint. They presented a very cogent argument for their rankings and I can’t fault their opinion. However, considering that they note that not every alcohol was tasted by them and many of their opinions were formed via gathered commentary in online groups – take their opinion as you will.
To me, the telling comment in their article was, “Either way, Kirkland’s spiced rum lacks the nuance and complexity of quality varieties of rum.”
If you’re a purist, sipping your rum for the experience, they’re probably completely correct as it’s just ‘flavored’ but then again, if you’re reading this site, you are here to learn how to mix flavors to create great drinks. A rum made in the manner of this one is really nothing more than a mixed drink (per se).
Kirkland Spiced Rum is now distilled in Puerto Rico (and boy did I learn to love some Puerto Rican rums on several trips the the island). Yes, it has natural flavors and caramel color. It is rated as 40% ABV (80 proof).
Here’s my take on Kirkland Signature Spiced Rum based on my direct tasting both as a stand alone and in a mix.
LOOK
Nice caramel color but since they use caramel coloring – I’m not going to use that as an indicator of quality.
The rum is thin – as most rums are. Not a lot of body. It quickly returns to the bottom of the glass. But then again just about every spirit does this.
SMELL
There is a hint of alcohol burn in the aroma – but you’d expect that from an 80 proof product.
The main scent I gather upon sampling is a smokey aroma.
TASTE
For a ‘flavored’ rum it’s pretty smooth. I get a somewhat nutty flavor when sipping it straight with a hint of the smokey flavor that the aroma promised.
When mixed in something like coke, the dominant flavor is the vanilla undertones that I got from the aftertaste when sipping it straight.
AFTERTASTE
When tasted straight – there’s a distinct vanilla taste that pops up after swallowing. The alcohol burn cuts in at the same time.
When mixed (such as the rum and coke mentioned before) the aftertaste has more of the vanilla than the nutty flavor. The smokey taste is also more evident than when sipped straight – probably due to the alcohol burn being subsumed in the mixer.
VERDICT
Look, from a purely flavor standpoint, I like this rum. It’s a great mixer for your weekend cocktails. Is it going to win prestigious awards from rum tasting competitions? Of course not. But in tune with the concepts of A Taste for Drink, it is flavorful and will enhance a cocktail it is used in.
So, yes, from a purist standpoint, it is not a ‘great’ rum because it is flavored rather than aged in a barrel with all those lovely ingredients. BUT it has a great taste whether straight up or in a drink so for me, it’s a good rum.
Read the article that started me on this commentary: https://www.tastingtable.com/879602/the-most-popular-kirkland-liquors-at-costco-ranked-worst-to-best/
Until next time, may all your drinks be tasty. Cheers.